Since FiOS is now available in Sarasota, I decided to try out the TV service. After 2 months of using and comparing to Dish Network, I’ve put together an extensive review…

If you’re thinking about upgrading to FiOS:

  1. Check with Verizon for availability: Can you get FiOS TV?
  2. Then follow this link for the current specials: FiOS TV Specials

You can read more details here: How to order FiOS

Ordering/Installation: Ordering online is straightforward if your address qualifies for FiOS service. You can select from the available installation dates and times. If you do not currently have FiOS Internet, the installation will take 4-6 hours. Verizon has put together a video to explain the installation process: FiOS TV Installation Video.

Once FiOS is installed to the outside of the home, the installer will usually use the existing coaxial cabling throughout the house to distribute the TV service. They will install new cable outlets at the rate of $54.99 per outlet. Regardless of whether or not you order internet service, Verizon will install a router and connect it to the FiOS network with a cat5 cable. It also connects to the home’s coaxial cable distribution to communicate with the set top boxes. The router downloads and provides all the guide data for the setup boxes. Currently Verizon offers 3 different setup boxes:

  • Motorola QIP 2500 - for standard definition viewing of FiOS TV ($4.99/mo lease fee per unit)
  • Motorola QIP 6200 - for high definition viewing of FiOS TV ($9.99/mo lease fee per unit)
  • Motorola QIP 6416 - for Digital Video Recording capability in standard or high definition ($12.99/mo lease fee per unit)

It IS possible to connect a TV directly to the FiOS TV Service, without any set top box, but this method only provides a limited set of channels (Approx 15). Verizon also offers a multi-room feature called Home Media DVR. For an additional $9/mo, the Motorola QIP 6416 is enabled to provide DVR access for up to 6 Motorola QIP 2500 set top boxes. If FiOS internet service is installed, this upgrade also enables Media Manager, which allows photos and music from a home computer to be played on the TV.

Programming: There are only 3 basic programming packages:

  • FiOS TV Premier - 200 channels
  • La Conexion - 140 channels
  • FiOS TV Local - 15 channels

In addition to the basic packages, Verizon offers these add-ons:

  • Movies - Includes Starz, Showtime, Encore, TMC, Flix and Sundance
  • Sports - Features Fox College Sports, Outdoor Channel, GolTV, The Golf Channel and more
  • Movies and Sports - 60 channels total
  • HBO
  • Cinemax
  • Spanish Package
  • WWE
  • Karaoke

The packages are really simple compared to most cable and satellite providers, and the channel lineups are extensive. I like the fact that the basic package includes National Geographic Channel (also available in HD). With Dish Network, only the most expensive package has NGC.

Any local High Definition broadcasts that exist are likely to be part of the FiOS TV Premier package. Local HD channels from a Dish or DirecTV are a different story. The newest setup boxes from the Dish and DirecTV are capable of receiving HD locals over the satellite feed, but the HD locals are only available in certain markets. In addition, in order to fit local market HD channels in the satellite feed, both providers are now using a more compressed MPEG4 stream, which means lower quality. Of course with or without a service provider, most people can hookup an antenna to an HDTV to get local HD channels.

The quantity of national HD channels are about average. Probably more than most cable providers, but not as many as Dish Network. Thats mostly due to the fact that Dish network acquired Voom HD and all its channels. When comparing price, I don’t think any other service provider provides as many channels as Verizon FiOS for a better price. More on channel lineups and cost comparisons coming soon.

Video On Demand: FiOS TV offers an extensive library of free and pay Video On Demand selections. Free selections include programming from Discovery, Discovery Health, Animal Planet, National Geographic Channel, Travel Channel, MTV, E!, VH1, Music Choice music videos, among others. The satellite providers cannot offer this. Currently all VOD selections are only available in standard definition which may be a disappointment for some people (like myself) for watching movies. Again, due to the bandwidth of FiOS, Verizon will continue to have a competitive advantage for VOD services. I would like to see them pair up with an online provider to provide even more selections for users. I’m just not sure how a company like Apple (iTunes) will provide their services to TV Service providers when it competes direclty with Apple’s Apple TV.

Quality: Standard definition channels are as good as it gets as far as I’ve seen. High definition channels are also as good as I’ve seen. Verizon will have a real competitive advantage over cable and satellite providers when it comes to picture quality thanks to the ample bandwidth that FiOS can provide. VOD service is currently only offered in standard definition, so quality really suffers. Most new movies are in widescreen format, and since the broadcast is in standard definition, the movie only shows in a small centered rectangle when watching on an HDTV. Of course most TV’s can zoom in, but quality suffers again.

With any of the movie packages, you have access to the VOD selections provided by those channels. Most of the time I preferred searching for the title and recording it live on the HD channel in HD quality rather than playing it through the VOD service. Of course you may have to wait a while for the title to be played again on the actual channel.

Set Top Boxes: From my experience the Motorola boxes are considerably better than the Scientific America boxes provided by many cable providers. With that being said, I still had problems with the Motorola boxes, mainly the QIP 6416 with DVR and HD capability. For starters the menu and usability is just average. TIVO users will probably not like it. No matter what you used before, this box will take some getting used to.

The recording options are basic, but effective. I did not experience any issues with missed recordings. Like most DVR boxes, it allows you to record series in a certain time slot or only shows marked as new.

The most annoying problem with the Motorola QIP 6416 (in its current software state) is its slow responsiveness. If you have a clear shot to the box and send a command or multiple commands, it will get them and process them, but you might have to wait a second or two. This becomes most irritating when skipping commercials. The Dish 942 set top box is instant. I can click the skip ahead button (more on that later) six times as fast as i can and it will have skipped 3 minutes (30 seconds each) when my finger stops clicking. The QIP 6416 will take about 1 second per skip ahead, so its done 6 seconds later.

Regarding the skip ahead feature… If you look at the remote provided with the Motorola QIP 6416, you won’t see one. However, as of the current firmware version, the feature IS provided, you just have to find a remote that can send the right command. The only way to do that is to either get a Harmony Remote (command is downloadable) or get any remote that can learn a command and find somebody that has a remote with THAT command.

The most significant issue with the QIP 6416 is problematic playback when the recording capacity is over 60%. This is not an exact measurement, but once the hard drive starts to get full, it seems to have problems much more frequently. I’m not sure Verizon can do anything other than hope Motorola can tweak the software to reduce these occurrences. In the future we may see Verizon switch to another set top box provider. I prefer my Dish 942 (made by JVC) over the Motorola any day. Although to be fair, the 942 had its fair share of issues when it was new (2 years ago).

On to the multi-room features. I applaude Verizon for offering such a feature since this is the way of the future and it provides a better end user experience. If you get the QIP 6416, it is capable of communicating with up to 6 QIP 2500’s (the regular set top box). Each 2500 can record to and watch any recorded content from the 6416 (up to 3 can watch different recordings at the same time). The only problem with this feature is that currently the 6416 cannot down convert High Definition content. So any HD programming recorded will NOT be viewable on the QIP 2500’s. This should be resolved in a future ffios software update.

The Media Manager feature allows you to connect to a home computer and view photos and play music through the TV. You have to install a program on the computer that scans for compatible content. I did get this feature to work, and it can be useful, but I feel its more of a gimmick. I’ll stick to using my Logitech Music Anywhere Wireless Music System for listening to computer music in the living room. Seeing the photos on the living room TV is a neat feature, but it takes too much effort to put together slideshow each time.

Other Features: FiOS offers something called FiOS widgets to expand the available features. Currently only two widgets are provided: a weather widget and traffic widget. With a click of a button, you can have this information appear on th screen .

PIP is still a work in progress. I was not able to get it to work on my system. There are PIP buttons on the remote, and a DVR capable set top box should not have any trouble provide such a features, it just doesn’t seem to be enabled at this time.

Overview:

Verizon FiOS is relatively new service that brings tons of features and potential. The only real downsides stem from the Motorola set top boxes. The service itself has been rock solid stable. You don’t have to worry about losing signal during rain. The method of delivery (fiber optic), in my opinion, makes it much more robust than both satellite and cable providers. If you’re looking for more reviews, be sure to read the user comments and experiences on PVRBlog.

If you’re thinking about upgrading to FiOS:

  1. Check with Verizon for availability: Can you get FiOS TV?
  2. Then follow this link for the current specials: FiOS TV Specials

You can read more details here: How to order FiOS

Update 5/21/2007: I will be adding a second FiOS TV post shortly on my continuing experience with FiOS, as well as some easy to compare breakdowns of FiOS vs satellite, and FiOS vs cable.

Update 7/25/2007: I’ve written a follow up on my experience, please check it out here: FiOS TV Review - Update

Update 11/16/2007: The FiOS software has been upgraded. Read the new review here: FiOS Interactive Media Guide.

Update 11/19/2007: Comments for this post are being continued at: FiOS Forum. Please post your questions and comments over there.

PHOTOS

Motorola QIP-6416
Motorola QIP-6416 Set-top box.

Motorola FiOS DVR connections
Motorola 6416 Back panel connections.

FiOS TV Guide
FiOS TV Guide Screen.

FiOS DVR Menu
FiOS TV DVR Menu.

FiOS Video On Demand Menu
FiOS TV Video On Demand Menu.

FiOS TV Mini Guide
FiOS TV Mini Guide.

FiOS TV Commercial Skip
FiOS TV Commercial Skip (It does exist!).

FiOS Optical Network Terminal
FiOS Optical Network Terminal mounted on an exterior wall (open).

Motorola FiOS remote control
FiOS remote control (Motorola 2500, 6200, and 6416).

FiOS Optical Network Terminal - Battery Backup
Battery backup for FiOS Optical Network Terminal mounted inside, plugged into an A/C outlet.

FiOS Optical Network Terminal
FiOS Optical Network Terminal mounted on an exterior wall.